battle

[obvious troll]

first to 5, keep it small. no animation, no vert sigs.

http://img208.imageshack.us/img208/8204/britneysig48zl.png

[Random Havoc]

Let's do this:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v319/Random_Havoc/boa.png

[Battōsai]

RH gmv.

IHY: your sig is pretty neat, but the smudge on the render looks... hmm... i don't know PS terms too well, but i'm going to go with oversmudged or saturated or something. Maybe if you looked at it, you might know what i mean. I dunno. Good sig none the less.

RH: love the sig man. Great stock, the lines are wierd, but professional looking. Now-a-days wierd=pro, at least that's how it seems. The RH is better than you had it, or maybe you didnt change it or soemthing, cuz it still seems a bit too pink, i think you should have used the color from the middle stripe, but if it doesn't work, it still looks fine the way it is. Nice job man ^_^

[Isis]

RH gmv.

I.H.Y, as Shuyin pointed out, the smudging doesnt really work though you can see that its a great sig.

RH: I love the simplicity of it and how the render somehow seems to pop out. Nicely done!

[Hits]

Random GMV. It flows better and has a better bg. But it lacks depth.

IHY, the sig feels too "hard" for me and not enough flow. The stock seems to be a little choppy at places.

[maximoose666]

Rh GMV.

RH: sweet tag. Good flow and effetcs. Lacks detail perhaps and lighting isn't that realistic, but I like it a lot anyways.

IHY: Tag just looks lower level. Good effetcs but lacks depth and lighting is off (light source you created in your tag is opposite place to the light source on the stock).

[Luso Clemens]

RH GMV, Even though it's so pink, I still like it.
It has a nice flow to it...
while the other one looks kinda.. bleek, ugly, no offense, but that's just my opinion... flipping hair does nothing for me.

[Ai]

RH GMV

RH - Nice it is perfect size for the stock and blends nicely with the background...Over all the sig creates a harmonious level of atmosphere that a user notices when looking at it

IHY - Mhmm....too small for the stock should be a bit bigger...And the center focus clashes too much with the outer edges...It would work better if you had the whole sig used without the plain black on the sides...In other words continue your work over the whole canvas...

[ChansteR]

good job both you, RH is winrar.