asian Vs. Thing

[Luso Clemens]

Thing
http://i47.photobucket.com/albums/f195/Asheth/gokusig.png
Asian
http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y86/bleached_asian/Siggies/Pink-girl-yay.png
5 votes to victory

[Princess Gheyfu]

Thing gmv.

Thing: Looks smoother and the effects look nice. Nice colors too. The render could use some blending though on the right side. Looks good, but needs some good lighting. :)

Asian: It looks a bit overcontrasted and the shrapen doesn't look to nice. The lighting on the right looks ok. The b/g looks a bit busy and the sharpen kills it. Try a bit more effects and try some lighting with the color dodge tool. :)

[Cassie]

I give my vote to Asian

Bigger is better, Asian's is bigger

Also, I prefer looking at females than males

As far as quality, both are good

Lastly, why does Asian's say Mool on the bottom right corner?

Because she gave it to mool as a gift :) - maximoose666

[Nomadic Dragon]

This was really hard but..
Thing GMV

Thing, the sig just looks nice. The colors are smooth and blend really nicely with the render. Over all a really good job.

asian, the sig looks a little over sharpened, but other than that it was pretty good.

[JamesThePhox]

Asian gmv.

Simple. Nice blending colors. The border is nice. The light is perfect and I like the overall softness of it.

Thing: Your Sig is good too. Except the background has lines going all over the place. I know it's supposed to look like he running, but things should be one directional. And is that a cigarette or a pole? o.o;

[Anil]

asian get's my vote...

both sigs are good... what leaned me one way was the patterning in asians sig.
Looks pretty. It's light and soothing.

[maximoose666]

Asian GMV

Asian: nice smooth colours and decent lighting, sig looks pretty. I would Lose the Lines.

Thing: It's a good sig but too small IMO, and the text on the pole really kills it. Sig feels cramped...

[Lunar]

asian gmv

asian: nice detials, the background fits with the stock and flows well. get rid of the white lines, and maybe fix ur lighting.. less sharpen maybe.

thing: its a good sig, no doubt one of ur best sigs u made. but its just that asians sig is better. its just the squares and the color bothers me

[Kootje]

At first I would say Asian, but after taken a closer look a say Things sig is better,blends better. I like both backgrounds, nice job both of you=D Close call but gmv Thing

[Chris`]

Thing gmv...
better use of colors, and better blending..the typo could have been blended in more, but thats not that much of an issue...

asian, your tag is monotone, and has confusing flow...because she at one angle, and the lines go off on a tangent...

[ChansteR]

asian won already, i guess i just missed it lol.