Seto vs Kootje Rematch

[Kootje]

Oke Seto since you want revenge we will battle again. The rules are simple no pentool,no animation, rest freestyle
My entry: http://i87.photobucket.com/albums/k157/kootje1/sigs/halov2.png
Filters,smudge, brushing
Good Luck first to 5

[Seto]

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v390/CoolGogeta/alex-sig.png
Filters, smugde (default brushes) and c4d only.
Cloud with his blade. It's a gift btw.
Hmmm, Kootje, the next time we do a battle with both the same picture indeed ;P.

[mrk]

Seto gmv.

Kootje your blurry render = too much of a turn-off

[Ruk]

Seto GMV

Seto : It's a nice sig it could use a few more effects around the render to make him appear less like he was cut and pasted on there. And touch up the light so it looks more "real". It looks pretty good thou

Kootje: It too over contrasted for my tastes and the BG is very blurry. The render could use some blending and or effects on it as well so it did not feel so cut out from the rest of the sig.

[omfgman]

@refried-lmao so sharpened renders "turn you on"?

anyway back to voting, to tell you the truth, i really dont fancy either

kootje: i dont really see any depth from your lighting. your render is a bit blurry and the way you put it on is as if you just erased something that was previously there and stuck your stock on.

seto: the sig that you put up for battle isnt one of your best works, the c4d colouring doenst really match the render. from wat i can tell there is no blending, and i dont think the render was even rendered properly, look at the part where the sword meets the shoulders.

anyway, i think seto GMV only because when i first looked at it i liked seto's a bit more, perhaps it was because the render was sharper

[Random Havoc]

kootje GMV.

I feellike a lot more work has been done to the sig that Seto's.

Kootje, yours is overcontrasted.
Seto, text is not appealing to me. Stock is taking half of the sig, so I can barely see work done of the tag.

[Hits]

seto gmv. It has better colors, lighting and depth imo. Plus it's a ff7 sig. \o/
kootje, I think there is too much white behind the stock. The bg looks choppy and unflowing.

[Sanzora]

Seto GMV

Kootje, sorry to say but this time Seto rules! Your render is a little blurry and your sig seems to have very little dimension to me.

Seto, I like the render and the colours you've chosen. I also think you've played with negative space quite well in this one. Awesome sig!

[Kootje]

Congrats Seto you win(nu staat het 1-1)=P

[Seto]

Whaha, ok then ;P.

Yeah I though ... The last time it was 2 styles ... Now it looks kinda the same.
Oh and people, I did something on the render:
Orignal:
http://img241.imageshack.us/img241/2623/finalfantasy1lz2jl1.png

Kootje, I can't wait till the next battle ^^.