Wanna Battle

[Kootje]

Just finished this Shikamaru sig, wanna battle first to 5
http://i87.photobucket.com/albums/k157/kootje1/sigs/Shikamaruv3.png
Good luck;)

[Cursive]

Aren't I just a battle-whore?
I really liked that tag... I'm not fully confident of my being better, well not quite confident at all... >.>
Anyway, here's my entry:
http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c6/quddus58/sakurasig1vfinal.jpg

[Sanzora]

Hinata GMV... I dunno, Kootje yours just seems odd to me... I dont get a nice flowing feeling off of it. Hinata's just seems to go together better.

[Reklaw X]

hmm hinata gmv on this one. His seems to just flow smoothly

[Tanya]

Kootje GMV - Top left corner and all of the bottom are wayy oversharpened. Gives it an ugly "dissolved" feel if ya know what I'm saying. Otherwise, it's a nice sig =)

Hinata. - Your B&W bg + colored render don't really compliment each other well imo. Compared to Kootje's, yours looks really bland, sry =\

[omfgman]

kootje gets my vote

even tho its too sharpened at the bottom, the lighting and blending are better than that of hinata's

[obvious troll]

Kootje gmv. better depth, effects and blending. some stuff is too sharp though, and both need work on lighting.

[Random Havoc]

Kootje GMV.

Kootje, from the work im seeing you do, your getting pretty advanced. Good job on the depth, although some places seems a bit over sharpened than they should be. Great sig, great job. Work on lighting and a bit on blending.

Hinata, now here is where I ahve a problem. I can't see wnough of your BG, I see about 60% of your stock, which IMO is taking wayy too much space for your sig. Usually lighter parts of the BG gives the illusion of a more close up focal, whereas darker parts of the BG emphesises on further distance of that BG effect. Yours is the complete opposite, which makes your sig seem very odd. (additional comment: maybe not this sig, but a lot of your sig has a powerful motion blurr effect on it, blurring out your sig just makes the focus go away on it, which shouldn't be your aim, you want to bring focus. If you must use a blurr (gaussian is recommended) set the layer to lighten and erase the face).

Hope you guys improve.

[Hayate-sama]

Sakura is a WHORE!!!!!

Anyways, Hinata gmv. Though the bg isn't all that, it has nice composition.

Kootje, you would have gotten my vote if you had not oversharpened the bg so much.

[Sacred-kun]

Kootje gmv, I'm really liking the effects and smudging in this one. The colors and depth are working really well, too.

Hinata, your's is just really blurry, maybe try adding more effects and colors.