1v1

[obvious troll]

I want someone advanced.
first to 6, rape at 4.

[Seto]

Mwah ok:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v390/CoolGogeta/burtstangelsiggymooi2to2.png

[obvious troll]

Nice tag!

meh, too tired to make something new =/
my entry:

http://i63.photobucket.com/albums/h152/iHate-You/Sigs/graveyard.png

[Random Havoc]

IHY GMV.

Sorry Seto, it seems like your new style is pwn, but it doesn't appeal to me in the slightest bit =x

What I really like about IHY's tag is that the negative space is strong on the side of her face but it doesn't look bad, so it really impressed me. Good depth good lighting, I lik the effects on the rigt bout I want to see more of that in a closer area.

[Iro]

I vote for Seto :)

I really like how he played with colors in that sig, the lighting is good, the stock looks smooth but the effects are simple. My only comment is that I think it still lacks something... probably one more effects and a text to go with that but other than that it is good already. 9/10

For IHY your stock looks sharpened. I really like how youve rendered your stock, the blending is ok (but is color lacking), the effects are good and the lighting is nice. 8.5/10

[Hayate-sama]

well lets see...tough choice, i guess IHY gmv. Though the colors of seto's stock is GREAT, the bg is fairly empty and boring. And IHY, i didn't like the right side of your tag.

[maximoose666]

I love both of them, but Seto GMV.

Seto - I just love the colours and depth and effects. And that stock always makes for an above-average outcome imo.

IHY - pwnage effects as well, but there is a small depth issue with the area immediately to the right of the render's head imo. Apart from that, lovely flow; it's a really nice sig as well :)

[bratr]

Seto, I like the colour. Feels warmer than that of IHY. also the females lips seem a touch too bright

[Hits]

IHY gmv. Better lighting and focal.

[Ericd014]

Got to go with Seto, sorry IHY, your good, but something just seems wrong for some reason about yours.

[Tanya]

IHY gmv - you have my C&C already =S

@Seto: It looks nice and all, but lacks in effects and seems boring.

[SumpfFuchs]

Seto GMV, your signature is simple, but uses color and overall flow to make a overall very good looking signature.

I Hate You, if there was some color in the face of the stock you would have gotten my vote.

[db]

Another ancient thread where nubbie still had his IHY nick xD

Seto gmv, I like the subtle effects here.
Nubbieee: The squarish rough effects near the waves are not that appealing but this is damn old xD.

Seto: 6
Nubbie: 4