Nubcake Vs Maximoose666 [Tie]

[Neve]

Welcome to the fourth round of the ClubBleach signature contest.

The theme for this round is: Fixed Stock (You must use one of the two following stocks as the main focal for your tag)

http://img154.imageshack.us/img154/1198/campfiregirlsvz3.th.png (http://img154.imageshack.us/my.php?image=campfiregirlsvz3.png)

http://img400.imageshack.us/img400/8531/minitokyomalescansmobilbz7.th.jpg (http://img400.imageshack.us/my.php?image=minitokyomalescansmobilbz7.jpg)

You may post once to wish your opponent good luck, but other than that, there will be no chatting.

The deadline for the signatures is 9:00pm GMT on Thursday, 8th of February. No entries will be accepted after that time, even if they are only a minute late.

You may NOT edit your entries. If you are found to have edited your entry after you have posted it, you will be removed from the round.

There is no voting by the public - voting may only be done by the class crew.

Please disable your personal signature when you post.

You may post your signature at any time.

[obvious troll]

gl maxi =)


**hmm, neve, I think you forgot the stocks =P no link on the thumbnails..

Sorry about that =P. Links added =D.
-Neve

[maximoose666]

gl nubbie :D

lol


*prepares to get pwnt* :(

[obvious troll]

bah, best I can do atm

http://i63.photobucket.com/albums/h152/iHate-You/Sigs/kira2v2.png

[maximoose666]

it's really lame when people delete my posts :D

http://i63.photobucket.com/albums/h142/maximoose666/Gifts%20To%20Others/DBgift.png

T'was Seto =P
-Neve

[Seto]

Sorry Maxi, rules :/.

Nubcake: 7/10
Colours are nice, but the lighting and the effects could use some work.

Maxi: 6,5/10
Colours and the effects are really nice. But I don't really like the composition, lighting and text ._. .

[Nichigo]

Tough choice.

Nub: 6/10
i don't really like the effects or the color choice here...but the stock is clean, lighting is good, and the depth is decent. NExt time, try to get more flow and smoother effects.

Maxi: 5/10
Too red. The monotonicity is unattractive imo. The focal is not very well defined...and there seems to be too much space where nothing's really going on. the angle of those lines really work against the text since they're not flowing together. Depth is good tho. btw..what's that thing on the render's head? It makes it look like he has a bald spot >.<

[Sacred-kun]

Nubcake: 6/10

The effects get abit repetitive and the colors are only good in some parts, imo. Try using a color other than white for the lighting. Abit messy.

Maxi: 7.5/10

Colors in this one are absolutely SMEX. The effects are really nice, too. Render placement could be better and the render itself could be bigger. The colors also shouldn't over power the stock's original colors either. Text fits nicely but I'm not liking the bars.

[Tanya]

nucake: 19 points
maxi: 19 points

It's a tie! Neve, you decide what to do since you're like the "head" of the contest :p

[Neve]

In the case of a tie, a win is counted for both participants :).