PDA

View Full Version : Graphic Novels


Kaze
05-19-2008, 10:40 PM
Firstly, I would like to say that finding a proper place to post this has been somewhat difficult, given the fact that we have no comics section.

It was either this place, or the manga section, though the topic really doesn't fit anywhere, however, western graphic novels have little in common with manga other than the fact that they're both referred to as sequential art. The literature section was the only option left, and not an entirely outrageous one, seeing that graphic novels take the comic book genre a few steps toward being a higher form of art.

As far as my choices go, I rather enjoy Alan Moore's work. Watchmen and V for Vendetta have been particularly pleasant to read, especially since they're propably the archetype of the graphic novel, taking comic book stories to a different level, one might say.

Anyway, do share some thoughts on the matter.

nx6
05-20-2008, 01:44 AM
Yes. I too enjoyed Moore's writing.

I was rather disappointed the V for Vendetta movie did not stay more true to the GN. If it had been a treatment more like Sin City it could have been epic. I've also read some of Miller's Sin City series as well, but I haven't read 300.

Kaze
05-23-2008, 12:54 PM
I've read 300. It was good, and, surprisingly, there were only a few discrepancies between the novel and the book.

And yeah, V for Vendetta could have been better, though the current version is pretty entertaining as well.

vlady
06-09-2008, 08:11 AM
I was a bit disappointed in V for vendetta thought it be better. Sin city the movie is great and the series is perfect in my opinion all around one of my favorites.

By watchment do you mean the Watchmen? Just wanna be clear in case I missed something? if you mean the watchmen then I have to say. I absolutely love it I liked it before it got popular with people and still like it.

nx6
06-09-2008, 09:20 AM
By watchment do you mean the Watchmen? Just wanna be clear in case I missed something? if you mean the watchmen then I have to say. I absolutely love it I liked it before it got popular with people and still like it.
Yeah, he means the Watchmen. It was a work by Moore so it was obviously a typo there. ;)

Kaze
06-09-2008, 10:34 AM
Haha. Yeah, it was obviously a typo. The word watchment doesn't even exist:P

So, yeah, Watchmen is a pretty damn good read. It puts new stuff like the Ultimates to shame, though I thought that was quite entertaining as well.