Signature Battle 2: Shaehl vs. ???

[Shaehl]

No animation
First to 5

Alright, I've been trying out a new style so I figured I'd test the result in a battle:

http://i12.photobucket.com/albums/a215/Shaehl/sigbg1.jpg

[Luso Clemens]

I'll take the challenge... Count me as your opponent

Ok, done with making the sig... go ahead and vote, people

http://i47.photobucket.com/albums/f195/Asheth/Nakosigsmall.png

[Anil]

Thing get's my vote.....

omg that sig is HUGE... but that style makes it all better... the brushing is excellent... awesome job...

Shaehl, stop matching up against Thing.... I like your sig but it can't compete...imo.... sorry buddy...

[Sacred-kun]

Thing gmv, I love the color scheme you used, the brushing is amazing, the render is nice and clean and the text suits the BG.

Shaehl, the render quality isnt that great, it's not blended that good, the colors don't match and a few red parts are too bright. The BG isn't that appealing to me and the text is all jaggedy.

[Nomadic Dragon]

Thing GMV

Shaehl..the render looks really low quality and it's blended odd.and the text is really hard to read. Your BG just looks kind of flat and really, really dark.

Thing..your sig is a bit on the large sig but it looks really good and the BG looks really nice the brushing is great.

[_Ink]

Shaehl...poor renders from screen shots are not to be used unless absolutely necessary, this kills it. Or if you do, you should learn how to play with filters and blends, otherwise it is not too good with just about any sig.
Love the background, but it is not too well defined. To match colors is fine, but this is poorly done, however, you are getting there.

hence..Thing GMV.
Clean and clear cut, but the background is not too creative. However, the twirls layered over makes for a clean and rustic look, which frankly doesn't go too well with the render, action vs rustic...not too matching IMO. Try a different and more "quiet" render next time.

[hasuke]

Thing. I prefer the look of it. Though the box around her name is a little...odd. Seems out of place.

[Luso Clemens]

Yay, I win
Nice battle, landslide as much as it was...

I would love to battle with you again sometime, Shaehl

[Shaehl]

Ah well, congrats Thing.